Log in

Lies, damn lies, and benchmarks - James Antill

Jul. 31st, 2009

02:47 pm - Lies, damn lies, and benchmarks

Previous Entry Share Next Entry


[User Picture]
Date:July 31st, 2009 08:59 pm (UTC)
For yum in particular...can you write up a howto on isolating each of the 10 steps for people doing valid bottleneck troubleshooting.

If I do see a significant slowdown, by enabling an optional plugin or feature (like repository scoring for example), having instructions on how to isolate which of the ten steps is seeing a bottleneck would be good.

In fact...you may even want to make sure you include the disableplugin step for completeness in the isolation instructions to help people self-determine if the problem is in a plugin codebase or in the base yum code.

(Reply) (Thread)
[User Picture]
Date:August 2nd, 2009 04:36 am (UTC)

Speed bugs are just bugs...


I'd advise finding speed bugs the same way I'd advise trying to find other bugs ... the most obvious step is to contact a yum developer (and def. not post to the closest mailing list :).

For instance when we recently pushed a regression which made "cost" go from seconds to minutes, a bunch of people spotted it (one even saying it worked fine if he commented out a particular line of code) and we eventually found the underlying problem (but it took me hours to work out what the problem was).

But I'm pretty sure a normal user wouldn't have been helped by detailed instructions on how to isolate parts of commands.

When I listed the "10 things the update command does" I didn't mean I thought it would be useful to time each of them, quite the opposite ... I meant it more that it was pretty suspicious to compare some of the operation, because a normal user will often end up doing all of the operation. Specifically if the rpmdb and repos. aren't in core, doing the IO to read hat data can easily dwarf the depsolve time and it's very rare for a user to not confirm the transaction (and again, the IO there will often be the longest part of the operation, by far). So even a 75% difference in depsolving can easily be only 1% of the update operation.

(Reply) (Parent) (Thread)